Source Policy

Evidence tiers

Tier 1: peer-reviewed literature

Use for pollinator associations, specialist bee relationships, seed ecology, restoration outcomes, germination ecology, and ecological-function evidence.

Tier 2: government and academic sources

Use for taxonomy, native status, conservation status, range, habitat, floristic descriptions, and ecosystem suitability.

Tier 3: regional expert and practitioner sources

Use for propagation, germination practices, cultivation notes, nursery production, seed handling, and practical establishment guidance.

Approved Tier 3 sources

Satinflower Nurseries is approved as a regional practitioner source when used with appropriate attribution and confidence labeling.

P15 adds a provider registry for commercial and practitioner supplier websites: Satinflower Nurseries, Northwest Meadowscapes, West Coast Seeds, and Premier Pacific Seeds. Provider rows are Tier 3 by default and may support supplier availability, cultivation clues, candidate discovery, and candidate mowability observations. They do not independently establish native status, ecological scores, pollinator scores, or final planting recommendations.

Provider sandbox rows must pass through an explicit approval manifest before they enter a tracked Vancouver PoC output. Approval does not make provider values reviewed ecological facts; imported rows remain candidate observations with source attribution and caveats.

Excluded sources

The following source must not be used anywhere in the project:

https://vancouver.ca/files/cov/vancouver-gri-planting-guidelines.pdf

This exclusion applies to citations, source-attribution fields, scoring rationale, species notes, and documentation.

Source hierarchy

Prioritize sources in this order:

  • Government and conservation-status sources.

  • Regional floras and herbarium-backed databases.

  • Peer-reviewed literature.

  • Conservation organizations.

  • Botanical gardens and universities.

  • Native plant nurseries and seed suppliers for commercial and cultivation data.

Attribution and review

Source/reference records require a stable source ID, source name, tier, and a citation or URL. Source attribution rows connect one source to one supported claim or field. Species-specific claims must include a stable BC-NPPD species ID.

External data manifests and media-derived extraction outputs are provenance records, not automatic facts. They become candidate evidence only after review, and their review status remains separate from evidence confidence.