Model Semantics

The model is the Daugherty (1991) case-study reproduced in ws3. This page records exactly what it computes and its known limitations.

The open-loop LP

A strata-based long-term timber harvest-scheduling LP. The forest is partitioned into development types (strata) by ecoclass, prescription, and age; the decision allocates stratum area to harvest over a 150-year horizon (15 x 10-year periods). The objective is maximization of present net value (PNV) at a 4% discount rate, with delivered-log prices escalating at 1%/yr for the first 50 years. A harvest-flow (even-flow) constraint ties each period’s harvest volume to within a tolerance of the reference period. Harvest regenerates the stand to age 0 (mature stands convert to the base managed prescription; managed stands regenerate to themselves).

This is a Model I formulation. Daugherty (1991) used Model II; the dynamic-inconsistency result is a property of the objective x flow-constraint x forest-structure interaction, not the variable-aggregation scheme (Gunn 2007, ch. 16 covers the Model I/II/III distinction). The ws3 Model II path is stubbed and is a deferred ws3 enhancement.

The case-study data

The thesis gives the case-study structure and anchor tables (Tables 5.1-5.5) but not the raw per-age yield curves, per-stratum areas, or detailed price/cost tables (those are in the archival USDA 1987 Umpqua EIS). The economics are reconstructed in fresh_daugherty.instance.reconstruct and calibrated to the Table 5.3/5.4 anchors; the yield-curve shapes are grounded in the Umpqua LRMP’s documented CMAI culmination ages (Table IV-3). This is a documented reconstruction with explicit assumptions (RECONSTRUCTION_ASSUMPTIONS), not a transcription.

Dynamic inconsistency

The open-loop LP is solved once over the full horizon (open-loop: the planner precommits future planners). The sequential-replanning simulator (fresh_daugherty.replan) re-solves from the realized state each period. The open-loop plan’s projected harvest diverges from the realized replanned trajectory: the plan is not followed, so it is not a credible basis for policy. This is the failure of Bellman’s principle of optimality, reproduced.

Known limitations

  • Reconstruction fidelity: the case-study economics are a documented reconstruction calibrated to the thesis anchors (PNV magnitudes match to ~1%; rotation ages are approximate, because the thesis’s irregular rotation pattern encodes the unavailable Umpqua yield tables).

  • Model form: Model I (not the thesis’s Model II, which ws3 does not yet compile with harvest-flow constraints); the two are equivalent only when they encompass the same management alternatives.

  • Replanning institution: by default each replan covers a full horizon rolled forward from the realized state with a fresh flow constraint (rolling horizon, reset flow history), as in the thesis. rolling_horizon=False keeps the original terminal date and carry_flow_history=True anchors each replan’s first harvest to the realized previous harvest; with both, each replan solves the exact tail of the original problem (the null test in tests/test_replan.py). History-derived bounds (carried anchor, realized-history rolling-mean floor) that are infeasible from the realized state are loosened minimally and the loosening is recorded (replan.minimal_history_relaxation).

  • Regeneration: a harvested stand regenerates under a fixed prescription (mature stands under planting, managed stands under their own prescription), and the objective has no treatment costs or commercial thinnings, so the thesis’s choice of management intensity at regeneration is not represented (probe and decision: planning/p16-regen-choice-probe.md).

  • Landbases: all eighteen are constructed from the thesis’s descriptions (pp. 78-80, Table 5.5); every choice the thesis leaves open is listed in instance.landbases.LANDBASE_ASSUMPTIONS.

  • Terminal constraints: as in the thesis (p. 77), every flow-constrained run requires the final-period standing volume to be at least 80% of the average inventory of the forest regulated under the regeneration prescriptions, and caps the final-period harvest at 120% of its long-term sustained yield, both at the thesis’s highest-PNV rotations (Table 5.3; lp.regulated_forest_targets); not used without a flow policy or with the E2 cap (thesis p. 80). The model’s own highest-PNV rotations differ: the shortest permitted rotation for every productive prescription, the longest for CM-CE (feis.model_lev); terminal_rotation="model" uses them, a sensitivity (grid_terminal_rotation_model.csv).

  • Price escalation: the 1%/yr real escalation (50 years) applies to each ecoclass’s net value per unit volume (stumpage less access cost), so the negatively valued CM-CE stratum also becomes more negative over time. The thesis escalated delivered log prices and stump-to-mill logging costs at the same rate, so stumpage rose 1%/yr, with hauling and road costs uniform across ecoclasses (p. 74); here the access costs differ by ecoclass and escalate with the net value. Every record also carries the metrics on the thesis’s observation window, periods 2-11 (*_2_11 columns).

  • Young-age yields: below the first tabled FEIS age, yield curves follow the cell’s calibrated Chapman-Richards shape scaled to the first FEIS value.

  • Mature-stand calibration: mature volumes are flat over age and chosen so that the model’s own discounted value of a period-1 harvest (4%) equals the thesis’s Table 5.4; period-2 values are within 13% except CM-CE (model.mature_value_check).