Synthetic strategic validation
P6.7 validates a complete 10-year synthetic strategic case: optimized portfolio, monitoring policy, fixed-cycle BAU, yearly report, and scenario replay.
The committed result is notes/reference/p6-validation.v1.json.
Case
build_synthetic_case creates:
three segments in one span with different lengths, service, risk, and uncertainty baselines;
ten yearly periods from 2026 to 2035;
one mowing option per segment and period;
a service target of 0.7 and a risk target of 0.4;
annual LiDAR monitoring with a value-of-information selection;
a four-year BAU cycle;
a 20-row optimized/BAU report;
a scenario with canonical portfolio and report digests.
Checks
Code |
Check |
|---|---|
|
Ten optimized and ten BAU yearly rows. |
|
Optimized rows remain within the period budget. |
|
Optimized service reaches the declared target. |
|
Monitoring cost is within budget and at least one policy decision exists. |
|
The comparison is like-for-like and the BAU plan is feasible. |
|
The report total equals the sum of optimized yearly rows. |
|
The scenario portfolio and report digests replay. |
validate_strategic_plan returns each check separately and a single pass/fail. A failed check is never
hidden behind the aggregate.
from brushline.strategic.validation import build_synthetic_case
case = build_synthetic_case()
assert case.validation.passed
assert case.portfolio.service_attainment >= 0.7
assert case.report.comparison.like_for_like
Results
On the committed case:
optimized service is about 0.707, present treatment cost is 920, and the plan is feasible;
BAU service is about 0.413 with a four-year cycle;
monitoring costs 200 and selects an annual LiDAR policy;
all seven checks pass and the scenario replays exactly.
Limits
The case is synthetic; it is not a field or realistic-corridor validation.
The option outcomes and contingencies are assumptions, not calibrated forecasts.
The validation proves contract and replay consistency, not global optimality.
No MIP/CP bound or external solver is used.