fresh-daugherty
fresh-daugherty is an open, transparent, and fully reproducible
reproduction of the modelling methods and case study of Daugherty (1991),
using ws3:
Daugherty, P. J. (1991). Credibility of Long Term Forest Planning: Dynamic Inconsistency in Linear Programming Based Forest Planning Models. PhD thesis, University of California, Berkeley.
Daugherty (1991) proves that linear-programming forest-planning models solved as open-loop formulations admit dynamically inconsistent plans — plans that fail Bellman’s principle of optimality, i.e. plans whose tails a future planner re-solving from the realized state under the same goals would not follow. Such plans are not a credible basis for policy. The thesis was never published peer-reviewed and is effectively inaccessible (archival hard copy only), so the modelling trap it documents is repeatedly rediscovered.
This project reproduces the thesis stack openly so the result becomes citable and the trap detectable, and it backs a short peer-reviewed paper.
Status: v0.2.1 (phases P9-P19) is released and archived on Zenodo (version DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23604804; concept DOI 10.5281/zenodo.21981433); it holds the records behind the manuscript
(results/experiments/). The current plan is planning/v0.2.0-plan.md;
ROADMAP.md is the issue-tracker view.