Daugherty, P. J. 1991. Credibility of Long Term Forest Planning: Dynamic Inconsistency in Linear Programming Based Forest Planning Models. PhD thesis, University of California, Berkeley.
Project
FRESH-Daugherty dynamic-inconsistency reproduction
An open, reproducible reproduction of Daugherty's 1991 analysis of dynamic inconsistency in linear-programming forest planning models.
FRESH-Daugherty is an open, transparent, and reproducible reproduction of the modelling methods and case study in Daugherty (1991), Credibility of Long Term Forest Planning: Dynamic Inconsistency in Linear Programming Based Forest Planning Models.
The original thesis shows that open-loop LP forest-planning models can produce dynamically inconsistent plans that fail Bellman's principle of optimality, making them an unreliable basis for policy and trade-off analysis. The thesis was never published peer-reviewed and is effectively inaccessible, so the project reproduces the model stack openly to make the result citable and the modelling trap detectable.
The reproduction implements the Daugherty open-loop harvest-scheduling LP in WS3 (Model I; Model II is not implemented), a sequential-replanning simulator that measures the occurrence and magnitude of dynamic inconsistency, and case-study experiments across initial forest conditions, harvest policies, and interest rates. It also adds four extension experiments.
Version v0.2.1 is released and archived on Zenodo, with experiment records and curated summaries backing a short peer-reviewed paper.
Status
- Ongoing methodological reproduction
People And Roles
- FRESH Lab: project team
Outputs
- GitHub repository
- Documentation
- WS3 reproduction of the Daugherty open-loop LP
- Sequential-replanning simulator and experiment records
- Zenodo archive and manuscript support