Open FFS treatment effects

Purpose

ws4.fire.treatment_effects pairs pre- and post-treatment measurements from the public National Fire and Fire Surrogate study and summarizes changes in canopy cover, live basal area, and surface fuel.

Source

USDA Forest Service Research Data Archive RDS-2016-0009. This is open public data from US FFS sites, not a BC treatment inventory.

Results

Median percent change by treatment:

Treatment

Canopy cover

Live basal area

Surface fuel

burn-only

−3.1%

−0.8%

−45.2%

thin-only

−10.8%

−28.5%

+50.6%

thin-burn

−22.9%

−29.0%

−3.5%

control

+6.4%

+0.8%

−8.3%

The tradeoff is explicit: thinning alone increases surface fuel, while burning reduces it. Thin-burn reduces both canopy structure and surface fuel.

Limits

  • US FFS sites, not BC.

  • The mapping from measured changes to FBP fuel/canopy inputs is a separate modelling choice.

  • BC Wildfire CRI Fuel Treatments are marked Access Only and are not used.

  • No operational claim.

Report: notes/reports/ffs-treatment-effects.md.