Fire-treatment evidence

Purpose

This page records published fuel-treatment effect ranges and the comparison gate WS4 will use once it can simulate a treatment prescription.

WS4 currently has no thinning, prescribed-fire, or fuel-load treatment pathway. It has containment/firebreak masks and a small VRI treatment-label mapping. A containment simulation must not be reported as validation of the fuel-treatment ranges below.

Published evidence

Treatment

Mean severity reduction

Source

Thinning + prescribed fire

62–72%

Davis et al. 2024

Prescribed fire only

62%

Davis et al. 2024

Thinning + pile burning

62%

Davis et al. 2024

Thinning only

27%

Davis et al. 2024

Treatment older than 10 years

28%

Davis et al. 2024

Source: Davis et al. (2024), Forest Ecology and Management 561:121885, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foreco.2024.121885. The values are western-US conifer meta-analysis means, not a BC-specific transfer value.

Available mechanism

ws4.fire.treatment.apply_fuel_treatment converts a declared mask of burnable cells to an explicit FBP fuel type. It requires the caller to name the replacement and refuses to modify non-fuel cells. It does not choose a prescription, fuel type, or treatment extent.

Comparison gate

ws4.fire.treatment.classify_effect computes the fractional reduction from a supplied untreated and treated metric. It reports whether the result is below, within, or above the published interval.

Decision

No-go for treatment-effect validation now. The evidence registry is usable, but a WS4 simulation cannot be scored against it until a treatment prescription changes fuel and canopy structure in the fire model.

A generic fuel-conversion mechanism now exists, but the prescription mapping is still missing: which FBP fuel type represents thinning, prescribed fire, or surface-fuel reduction is an expert decision, not a default. Until that mapping is supplied, report containment/firebreak effects separately.