Sampled budget chance constraint

This is a static plan with a sampled budget chance constraint. The model allows at most two of 20 training paths to exceed the annual budget in each year, while keeping capacity hard across all training paths.

This is not a distributional chance-constrained guarantee. It is a sampled constraint test.

Results

Training: 20 paths; maximum budget violations 2 per year.

Plan

5-year cost P10-P90

Mean risk

Budget violation

Chance-constrained

198,743-247,028

0.0516

21.0%

Scenario-robust

199,567-248,028

0.0516

23.0%

Nominal balanced

269,679-333,777

0.0294

93.0%

The chance plan costs 220,976 CAD nominally, has 170 actions, and is capacity-feasible under all training paths. Its out-of-sample budget violation is 21%, only two points below the scenario-robust plan.

Why the gain is small

Capacity remains hard across all 20 training paths. That constraint binds first, so relaxing budget chance alone barely changes the selected treatment schedule. A meaningful next step would be to chance-constrain capacity or add recourse.

Limits

  • Sampled chance constraint, not a distributional guarantee.

  • Budget chance only; capacity is hard.

  • 20 training paths; 100 test paths.

  • No risk, weather, outage, safety, asset-owner priority, or field-calibration model.