Deferral-fraction frontier

The 20% scope target was chosen as an example. This frontier sweeps risk-ranked first-year deferral from 0% to 25% and reports the trade between calendar completion, fixed-future residual risk, recovery, and five-year cost.

Completion uses the assumed 75/105-day weather/outage calendars. Recovery uses fixed future factors; it is a screening frontier, not out-of-sample validation for every point.

Results

Target

Actual deferred

Completion 75

Completion 105

Fixed final loss

Recovery final loss

Reopt cost

0%

0.0%

13.2%

61.9%

0.0000

0.000003

298,723

5%

6.0%

19.7%

67.7%

0.0109

0.000003

295,027

10%

11.1%

27.9%

70.0%

0.0209

0.000003

292,078

15%

16.1%

39.3%

79.7%

0.0307

0.000000

289,012

20%

21.3%

47.1%

87.4%

0.0413

0.000003

285,825

25%

26.0%

53.3%

91.9%

0.0509

0.000000

283,082

All targets are first-year budget-feasible in 100% of scenarios.

Higher deferral improves calendar completion and lowers five-year reoptimized cost, but increases fixed-future residual risk. Under fixed-factor recovery, the final risk gap is essentially closed at every tested fraction.

Limits

  • Fixed-factor recovery is a screening result; only the 20% point has out-of-sample future validation.

  • Risk ranking is first-year only and whole actions are deferred; actual fractions overshoot.

  • No single utility or risk appetite is optimized; the table is a frontier, not a recommendation.

  • Weather and outage calendars are prototype assumptions.

  • No recurrence, safety, asset-owner priority, or field calibration.