Weather/outage remedies

The remedy comparison tests whether additional crew/machine capacity, a smaller first-year scope, or a longer window improves the assumed weather/outage calendar result. It uses the same 20 rolling episodes and 50 calendars per episode as the all-episode stress scan.

Added capacity is costed at 1,200 CAD per crew-day and 900 CAD per machine-day against the 60,000 CAD first-year budget. These are prototype rates, not contractor quotes.

Results

Remedy

Scenario full completion

Added cost P50

Total cost P50

Budget feasible

Baseline

13.2%

0

59,875

100%

+1 shared crew

13.2%

10,800

70,761

0%

+1 shared crew + machine

92.9%

80,850

140,800

0%

+1 shared machine

13.2%

8,100

68,061

0%

10% scope reduction

23.4%

0

53,888

100%

20% scope reduction

44.9%

0

47,900

100%

10% scope + 90-day

54.9%

0

53,888

100%

20% scope + 90-day

66.4%

0

47,900

100%

90-day window

41.5%

0

59,875

100%

105-day window

61.9%

0

59,875

100%

20% scope + 105-day

93.9%

0

47,900

100%

The 20% scope + 105-day case is the best budget-feasible completion case. It is a proportional scope reduction, so the risk effect of deferring 20% of work is not evaluated here.

A crew alone or machine alone does not improve completion because mowing and mechanical work require both. The crew-plus-machine case is the strongest full-scope completion remedy, but its median total first-year cost is about 140,800 CAD against the 60,000 CAD budget.

Limits

  • Capacity and scope remedies are hypothetical scheduling tests, not contractor commitments.

  • Crew-day and machine-day rates are prototype assumptions, not contractor quotes.

  • Scope reduction applies proportionally to work-item hours; it is not a risk-ranked deferral policy, and the deferred risk is not evaluated.

  • The calendar is assumed: independent weather loss and a fixed outage block.

  • Only first-year shift scheduling is tested; access, later years, and safety are not certified.