Rolling recovery after deferral

The fixed-future trajectory showed that first-year scope deferral leaves a persistent risk gap. This experiment asks whether re-optimizing future years with the rolling policy closes that gap.

The first-year risk-ranked deferral is fixed; later years are re-solved with the same annual factors, the persistence forecast, and a two-year lookahead. This is not a stochastic multi-year policy guarantee.

Results

Case

2027

2028

2029

2030

2031

Mean loss

Final loss

Full policy

0.1133

0.0147

0.0060

0.0067

0.0073

0.0

0.0

Deferred, no reoptimization

0.1546

0.0560

0.0473

0.0480

0.0486

0.0413

0.0413

Deferred, rolling reoptimization

0.1546

0.0318

0.0063

0.0067

0.0073

0.0117

0.000003

Mean recovery: 0.0295. Final recovery: 0.0413.

The rolling policy spends the next year closing most of the deferral gap. By 2029 the risk path is close to the full plan, and the final-year gap is effectively zero.

Cost

Mean five-year treatment cost over the 20 episodes:

  • full policy: 298,797 CAD;

  • deferred, no reoptimization: 285,970 CAD;

  • deferred, rolling reoptimization: 285,825 CAD.

The re-optimized path retains most of the first-year cost saving while recovering the risk gap under the fixed-factor assumptions.

Limits

  • First-year deferral is fixed; later plans cannot reverse it.

  • Annual factors are fixed from the rolling episode; no new uncertainty is sampled.

  • The rolling policy is a persistence-forecast heuristic, not a global or stochastic optimum.

  • Risk ranking is first-year only.

  • No recurrence, weather, outage, safety, or asset-owner priority model.