Added-crew versus window remedy
One relief mowing crew and machine were added for all five years and compared with extending the fall window. Calendar-aware execution is used throughout.
Added-resource cost uses:
1,200 CAD per crew-day;
900 CAD per machine-day;
8% supervision;
10% overhead;
2,500 CAD seasonal overhead per relief crew-year.
Results
20 episodes, seed 7, 59 segments.
Case |
Window |
Extra crews |
Completed P50 |
Mean risk |
Action cost P50 |
Added resource P50 |
Total cost P50 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Baseline |
75 |
0 |
87.6% |
0.0502 |
264,047 |
0 |
264,047 |
Extra crew |
75 |
1 |
98.0% |
0.0332 |
293,706 |
529,411 |
823,084 |
Window |
90 |
0 |
95.9% |
0.0365 |
285,490 |
0 |
285,490 |
Window |
105 |
0 |
98.1% |
0.0333 |
294,012 |
0 |
294,012 |
The added crew recovers almost all calendar-aware scope, but its total cost is about 823,000 CAD versus 294,000 CAD for the 105-day window. Under these assumptions, extending the window is substantially cheaper than adding a crew and machine. Seasonal overhead for the window itself is not modelled.
590-segment scale test
A replicated 590-segment instance uses 30 base crews, 10 relief mowing crews, and 10 relief machines. The fixed plan is exact; annual re-solves use Fresh Solutions.
Case |
Window |
Extra crews |
Completed P50 |
Mean risk |
Action cost P50 |
Added resource P50 |
Total cost P50 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Baseline |
75 |
0 |
84.5% |
0.0667 |
2,536,614 |
0 |
2,536,614 |
Extra crew |
75 |
10 |
98.3% |
0.0325 |
2,931,649 |
5,357,421 |
8,278,357 |
Window |
90 |
0 |
95.9% |
0.0368 |
2,844,469 |
0 |
2,844,469 |
Window |
105 |
0 |
98.1% |
0.0328 |
2,931,649 |
0 |
2,931,649 |
Runtime: fixed exact 49.7 s; remedy sweep 344.4 s for 20 episodes.
The extra-crew action cost already equals the 105-day window total, so any positive resource rate makes the crew option more expensive. At 59 segments, the break-even resource rate is only 0.058% of the assumed day rates. The window remedy dominates under these assumptions.
Limits
59 segments only; not a 590-segment cost comparison.
Extra crew and machine are available for all five years.
Added resource cost uses prototype day rates and overhead fractions.
Window extension carries no added seasonal overhead or supervision in this comparison.
No safety, access, asset-owner priority, or field-calibration claim.