Added-crew versus window remedy

One relief mowing crew and machine were added for all five years and compared with extending the fall window. Calendar-aware execution is used throughout.

Added-resource cost uses:

  • 1,200 CAD per crew-day;

  • 900 CAD per machine-day;

  • 8% supervision;

  • 10% overhead;

  • 2,500 CAD seasonal overhead per relief crew-year.

Results

20 episodes, seed 7, 59 segments.

Case

Window

Extra crews

Completed P50

Mean risk

Action cost P50

Added resource P50

Total cost P50

Baseline

75

0

87.6%

0.0502

264,047

0

264,047

Extra crew

75

1

98.0%

0.0332

293,706

529,411

823,084

Window

90

0

95.9%

0.0365

285,490

0

285,490

Window

105

0

98.1%

0.0333

294,012

0

294,012

The added crew recovers almost all calendar-aware scope, but its total cost is about 823,000 CAD versus 294,000 CAD for the 105-day window. Under these assumptions, extending the window is substantially cheaper than adding a crew and machine. Seasonal overhead for the window itself is not modelled.

590-segment scale test

A replicated 590-segment instance uses 30 base crews, 10 relief mowing crews, and 10 relief machines. The fixed plan is exact; annual re-solves use Fresh Solutions.

Case

Window

Extra crews

Completed P50

Mean risk

Action cost P50

Added resource P50

Total cost P50

Baseline

75

0

84.5%

0.0667

2,536,614

0

2,536,614

Extra crew

75

10

98.3%

0.0325

2,931,649

5,357,421

8,278,357

Window

90

0

95.9%

0.0368

2,844,469

0

2,844,469

Window

105

0

98.1%

0.0328

2,931,649

0

2,931,649

Runtime: fixed exact 49.7 s; remedy sweep 344.4 s for 20 episodes.

The extra-crew action cost already equals the 105-day window total, so any positive resource rate makes the crew option more expensive. At 59 segments, the break-even resource rate is only 0.058% of the assumed day rates. The window remedy dominates under these assumptions.

Limits

  • 59 segments only; not a 590-segment cost comparison.

  • Extra crew and machine are available for all five years.

  • Added resource cost uses prototype day rates and overhead fractions.

  • Window extension carries no added seasonal overhead or supervision in this comparison.

  • No safety, access, asset-owner priority, or field-calibration claim.