Out-of-sample recovery

The fixed-factor recovery test reused the original annual factors for 2028-2031. This test keeps the first-year risk-ranked deferral fixed and resamples future cost, productivity, and capacity factors independently for each future path.

Future years are re-solved with the rolling persistence forecast and a two-year lookahead. This is a stochastic recovery test, not a stochastic dynamic program.

Method

  • 20 rolling episodes.

  • First-year risk-ranked deferral: 20% target, 21.3% actual mean deferral.

  • Five independent future-factor paths per episode, 100 paths total.

  • 2028-2031 re-solved for each path.

  • Future factors sampled from the same lognormal assumptions as the rolling policy.

Results

Metric

P10

P50

P90

Mean

Final risk gap

-0.0078

-0.0010

0.0072

-0.0008

Recovery

0.0340

0.0421

0.0491

0.0421

Final gap within 0.005

—

87.0% of paths

—

—

A negative final gap means the reoptimized path ends below the full policy’s final risk. The median gap is slightly negative; 87% of paths are within 0.005 of the full policy.

Cost bands:

  • reoptimized: 284,835-286,788 CAD, mean 285,868;

  • no reoptimization: 227,290-272,072 CAD, mean 251,312;

  • full policy: 273,213-326,472 CAD, mean 299,052.

The reoptimized path spends more than no reoptimization to recover risk, but less than the full policy on average.

Limits

  • First-year deferral is fixed.

  • Future factors are independent draws; no serial correlation or calibrated forecast process.

  • Future years use a persistence forecast and two-year lookahead, not a stochastic dynamic program.

  • First-year risk ranking only.

  • No recurrence, weather, outage, safety, or asset-owner priority model.