Risk-ranked scope deferral
The proportional scope remedy defers hours mechanically. This comparison instead defers whole first-year actions ranked by lowest first-year risk reduction per hour, until about 20% of action hours are deferred.
This is first-year risk ranking, not a multi-year risk model. The actual deferred fraction can overshoot because whole actions are selected.
Network result
20 rolling episodes, 50 calendars per episode.
Target 20% of first-year action hours.
Mean actual deferred fraction: 21.3%.
Mean first-year risk loss: 0.0413.
Mean residual risk: 0.1546 (from a lower full-plan risk).
Median total cost: 47,226 CAD, budget-feasible in 100% of scenarios.
Case |
Scenario completion |
Mean risk loss |
Residual risk |
Budget feasible |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Risk-ranked 20% + 75-day |
47.1% |
0.0413 |
0.1546 |
100% |
Risk-ranked 20% + 105-day |
87.4% |
0.0413 |
0.1546 |
100% |
For context, a proportional 20% reduction has an estimated mean first-year risk loss of about 0.0448 under the same action-benefit accounting. The risk-ranked choice loses less first-year risk reduction, but its whole-action selection also has lower scheduling completion than the proportional 20% + 105-day case.
Interpretation
The risk-ranked 105-day case completes less of the assumed calendar than the proportional case, but it protects more first-year risk reduction per deferred hour. Neither result is a multi-year risk recommendation. A real deferral decision would need year-specific risk accounting, recurring treatment effects, and asset-owner priorities.
Limits
Ranking uses first-year risk reduction per action hour only.
Whole segment actions are deferred; actual deferred fraction can overshoot the target.
No multi-year risk, treatment recurrence, outage, or safety model.
Weather and outage assumptions are prototype values.
The MILP is exact only for the declared linear risk state at 59 segments.