Two-stage operational recourse

The first-year nominal balanced plan is fixed. After annual cost, productivity, and capacity factors are observed, the second stage defers whole actions by lowest first-year risk reduction per hour until the annual budget and crew-hour capacity are satisfied.

This is an operational recourse evaluation for one year, not a multi-year stochastic dynamic program.

Results

  • First-stage plan: nominal balanced, 46 first-year actions.

  • 100 factor scenarios, seed 23.

  • Budget 60,000 CAD/year; capacity 6,000 hours/year.

Metric

Static execution

Two-stage recourse

Budget violation

44.0%

0.0%

Capacity violation

0.0%

0.0%

Cost P50

57,939

57,939

Cost P90

71,471

59,592

Completion P50

100.0%

100.0%

Mean completion

100.0%

93.98%

Mean risk loss

0.0000

0.0121

The mean deferred workload is 2.75 actions and 60.2 crew-hours. The second stage guarantees budget and capacity feasibility for the first year while retaining most of the planned work and risk reduction.

Limits

  • First-year only.

  • First-stage plan is fixed; no strategic re-optimization.

  • No weather, outage, future re-planning, or multi-year risk model.

  • Deferral ranking is first-year risk reduction per hour only.

  • No field calibration, safety, or asset-owner approval.

Multi-year annual recourse

The same deferral rule is applied independently to every year of the five-year nominal plan. The first-stage plan remains fixed; there is no future strategic re-optimization.

  • 100 annual-factor scenarios, seed 23.

  • Static any-year budget violation: 93.0%.

  • Recourse any-year budget violation: 0.0%.

  • Static mean risk: 0.0294; recourse mean risk: 0.0330.

  • Mean completion: 93.9%; completion P50 95.1%.

  • Mean deferred workload: 13.0 actions, 306.0 hours.

The annual recourse rule keeps the five-year plan budget- and capacity-feasible while retaining most of the planned work. The risk increase is small but not eliminated. This remains a one-stage fixed plan with annual operational recourse, not a stochastic dynamic program.