Rolling policy with recourse

This comparison combines the fixed first-year nominal plan with the rolling policy and annual operational deferral. It compares four cases on the same annual-factor paths:

  • static fixed plan;

  • fixed-future annual recourse;

  • rolling-only;

  • rolling recourse.

The first year is fixed. Later years are re-solved with the rolling persistence forecast and a two-year lookahead. In the recourse cases, the current year’s actions are deferred by lowest first-year risk reduction per hour when budget or capacity is exceeded.

Results

20 episodes, seed 7.

Policy

Budget violation

Completion P50

Mean completion

Mean risk

Cost P50

Static fixed

95.0%

100.0%

100.0%

0.0294

300,711

Fixed-future recourse

0.0%

93.1%

93.3%

0.0335

279,595

Rolling-only

55.0%

100.0%

100.0%

0.0293

300,236

Rolling recourse

0.0%

99.4%

98.8%

0.0349

297,451

Rolling recourse restores almost all first-year scope while remaining budget- and capacity-feasible. It costs more future treatment than fixed-future recourse and does not reduce mean risk in this run. The risk metric mixes the fixed first-year risk loss with re-optimized future years; it is not a like-for-like multi-year risk improvement.

590-segment scale test

A replicated 590-segment stress instance uses the same policy. The fixed plan is exact; annual rolling re-solves use the Fresh Solutions heuristic.

Policy

Budget violation

Completion P50

Mean risk

Cost P50

Static fixed

95.0%

100.0%

0.0291

3,008,496

Fixed-future recourse

0.0%

93.9%

0.0329

2,811,913

Rolling-only

55.0%

100.0%

0.0290

2,969,701

Rolling recourse

0.0%

99.6%

0.0340

2,942,470

Runtime: fixed exact 47.1 s; rolling heuristic 87.2 s for 20 episodes. The instance is replicated, not a real 590-segment network, and the heuristic makes no global-optimality claim.

Limits

  • Fixed first year.

  • No weather, outage, recurrence, safety, or asset-owner priority model.

  • First-year risk ranking for deferral.

  • Rolling policy is a persistence-forecast heuristic, not a stochastic dynamic program.

  • 20 episodes.