Weather/outage-aware recourse
This comparison adds an assumed annual crew calendar to the rolling-recourse policy. Each year observes cost, hours, and capacity, and the execution calendar contains five fixed outage days plus independent 20% weather-loss probability per day in a 75-day fall window.
Three cases are compared:
calendar-naive: keep the resource-feasible plan and accept partial execution;
forecast-aware: plan against an independent synthetic forecast calendar, then execute under the actual calendar;
calendar-aware: defer unscheduled actions until every retained action fits the observed calendar.
The forecast is a synthetic draw from the same assumed distribution, not a forecast product. The observed-calendar case uses within-year calendar information before deferral. These are calendar policies, not stochastic dynamic programs.
Results
20 episodes, seed 7.
Case |
Budget violation |
Completed scope P50 |
Retained scope P50 |
Mean risk |
Cost P50 |
Unscheduled h |
Calendar deferrals |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Calendar-naive |
0.0% |
88.4% |
99.4% |
0.0480 |
297,595 |
605.9 |
0.0 |
Forecast-aware |
0.0% |
86.2% |
88.3% |
0.0526 |
264,470 |
64.7 |
39.2 |
Calendar-aware |
0.0% |
87.6% |
87.6% |
0.0502 |
264,047 |
0.0 |
39.9 |
Forecast awareness reduces unscheduled work from 605.9 h to 64.7 h, but forecast error remains. Observed-calendar awareness eliminates unscheduled retained work but costs about 1.4 percentage points of mean scope versus forecast awareness and raises mean risk. Neither aware case lowers risk; both convert partial work into deferred scope.
590-segment scale test
A replicated 590-segment instance scales the workforce to 30 crews and 30 machines. The fixed plan is exact; annual re-solves use Fresh Solutions.
Case |
Budget violation |
Completed scope P50 |
Retained scope P50 |
Mean risk |
Cost P50 |
Unscheduled h |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Calendar-naive |
0.0% |
85.9% |
99.6% |
0.0617 |
2,942,470 |
7,377 |
Forecast-aware |
0.0% |
83.6% |
86.4% |
0.0713 |
2,539,520 |
681.5 |
Calendar-aware |
0.0% |
84.5% |
84.5% |
0.0667 |
2,536,614 |
0.0 |
Runtime: fixed exact 48.6 s; 20 weather episodes 220.8 s. Forecast error leaves 681.5 h unscheduled at scale, while observed-calendar awareness eliminates unscheduled retained work. The instance is replicated, not a real network, and the heuristic makes no global-optimality claim.
Limits
Forecast awareness uses a synthetic calendar draw, not a weather forecast.
Observed-calendar awareness uses within-year information before deferral.
Weather loss is independent per day and assumed, not measured.
The outage block is assumed, not an asset-owner schedule.
Whole actions are deferred when they cannot be completed, so the aware cases are conservative.
No safety, asset-owner priority, access, or field-calibration claim.