Static budget-headroom plans

The static-plan comparison asks what happens when an agency cannot re-plan every year. It evaluates existing frontier plans against a common actual annual budget and the same annual cost, productive-hours, and capacity factors used by the rolling-policy experiment.

This is candidate selection from the existing frontier, not robust optimization. The candidate’s nominal budget is the budget used to build its treatment schedule; the actual budget is the common 60,000 CAD/year constraint against which all candidates are tested.

Network result

  • 8,737 ha, 59 segments, 2027-2031.

  • 20 annual-factor episodes, seed 7.

  • Actual budget 60,000 CAD/year; actual capacity 6,000 hours/year.

  • Budget-risk limit for the starred candidate: 5%.

Candidate

Nominal budget

5-year cost P10-P90

Mean risk

Budget violation

milp-budget-20000

20,000

88,293-110,903

0.1741

0.0%

milp-budget-30000 *

30,000

132,246-166,121

0.1009

0.0%

milp-budget-45000

45,000

198,832-249,729

0.0526

10.0%

milp-budget-60000

60,000

265,469-333,438

0.0294

95.0%

milp-budget-80000

80,000

353,128-443,639

0.0142

100.0%

milp-budget-100000

100,000

442,405-555,672

0.0093

100.0%

The 30,000 CAD target is the lowest-risk candidate within the 5% budget-risk limit. The 45,000 CAD target has lower risk but breaches the actual budget in about 10% of episodes. The 60,000 CAD balanced plan has lower risk still but breaches in 95% of episodes because it commits a schedule that uses essentially the whole nominal budget.

Decision trade

The static candidates leave budget headroom by building to a lower nominal budget:

  • 30,000 target: 132,246-166,121 CAD five-year cost, risk 0.1009, no budget violation.

  • 45,000 target: 198,832-249,729 CAD, risk 0.0526, 10% budget violation.

  • Rolling policy: 298,123-299,398 CAD, risk 0.0296, no budget violation.

Rolling gives much lower risk than the static candidates at a higher treatment cost. The static 30,000 target is the low-cost option, not the risk-minimizing option.

Limits

  • Candidate evaluation, not robust optimization or a probabilistic guarantee.

  • The actual budget is fixed at 60,000 CAD/year for this comparison.

  • Twenty episodes and independent annual factors are a demonstration sample.

  • The MILP is exact only for the declared linear risk state at 59 segments.

  • No field calibration, outage constraint, safety certification, or asset-owner approval.